Shift-left security is the practice of applying security controls as early as possible in the software development life cycle (SDLC). This approach aims to integrate security into the development process from the beginning, rather than treating it as an afterthought.
Here's a breakdown of key aspects of shift-left security based on the sources:
Early Flaw Detection: The primary goal of shift-left security is to identify and address code flaws during the development stage, before they become vulnerabilities in production. This is crucial because the time, money, and effort required to fix a flaw is significantly less during development compared to later stages.
Proactive Approach: Shift-left security encourages a proactive approach to security, rather than a reactive one, by implementing security measures throughout the development process.
Tools and Techniques:
Static Application Security Testing (SAST): SAST solutions analyze code as developers are writing it and offer real-time remediation suggestions. SAST tools can also be integrated into automated pipelines to ensure that builds that do not pass security policies will fail.
Software Composition Analysis (SCA): SCA scans software and creates a bill of materials (BOM), listing the components of the application and their versions. This is useful for managing third-party dependencies and quickly identifying vulnerable components.
Partnership and Collaboration: Successfully implementing shift-left security requires a collaborative approach that includes developers and project managers.
Developer Buy-in: Developers are more likely to support a security program if they understand the reasons behind it and have a chance to voice their concerns.
Project Manager Involvement: Project managers should be briefed on security requirements to ensure security is considered from the start of new projects.
Clear Standards and Expectations: It's important to establish clear security standards and communicate them to developers, providing them with a framework for secure coding.
Positive Culture: Creating a positive culture around security is important for a successful shift-left approach.
By shifting security to the left in the SDLC, organizations can reduce remediation costs, improve code quality, and minimize the risk of vulnerabilities in production, ultimately leading to a more secure development process.
What are three proactive shift-left security actions?
Three proactive actions that can boost shift-left security in the Software Development Life Cycle (SDLC) are:
Creating and communicating standards for application security: This involves establishing clear expectations for security success and communicating them to developers. This provides developers with a framework for secure coding and ensures everyone is on the same page regarding security requirements.
Providing secure coding courses and incentives: Offering training in secure coding practices helps developers improve their skills in this area. In addition, rewarding developers who go above and beyond in security helps to create a positive culture around security and encourages buy-in from developers.
Involving project managers in security requirements: By briefing project managers on security requirements, they can ensure that security is considered from the start of new projects and can reach out to security personnel when new projects are initiated. This helps to avoid security being treated as an afterthought and ensures security is integrated into the development process early on.
These actions contribute to a proactive approach to security, integrating it into the SDLC from the beginning and fostering a culture of security awareness and collaboration.
How does early security integration impact development timelines?
Integrating security early in the development process, known as "shift-left security," can positively impact development timelines by reducing the time, money, and effort required to fix security flaws. Here's how:
Reduced Remediation Costs: When code flaws are discovered during the development stage of the software development life cycle (SDLC), the cost to fix them is significantly less than if they were discovered in production or, worse, after being exploited.
Real-time Feedback: Static application security testing (SAST) solutions can analyze code as developers are writing it and provide real-time remediation suggestions.
Automated Security Checks: SAST can be integrated into the automated pipeline to fail builds that do not meet security policies. This helps to ensure that security flaws are addressed before they make it into production.
Early Detection: By using SAST tools and other methods early in the development process, vulnerabilities can be found before they are deployed, thus preventing emergency remediation efforts later.
Dependency Management: Software composition analysis (SCA) scans your software to create a bill of materials (BOM) which lists the components of the application and their versions. This helps to manage third-party dependencies and allows for a quick search when a zero-day vulnerability, such as Log4j, occurs, so the impact can be determined quickly.
Partnership with Developers: Involving developers in the security process, getting their input on policies and running proof of concepts for new security technologies, fosters a sense of partnership and encourages buy-in from the development team. This reduces friction and resistance to security measures.
Clear Expectations: Setting clear standards for application security and communicating them to developers will give developers expectations for security success.
Project Manager Involvement: Briefing project managers on security requirements helps ensure that security is considered from the start of new projects.
What are two fundamental development success criteria?
The two most fundamental success criteria of development are:
Functionalizing business requirements
Meeting deadlines on time
These criteria are important to keep in mind when implementing a shift-left security approach, as the goal is to improve security without negatively impacting these key objectives of development.
Why is developer buy-in crucial for shift-left success?
Developer buy-in is crucial for the success of shift-left security because it fosters a collaborative environment and ensures that security measures are effectively integrated into the development process. Here's why:
Partnership, Not Dictatorship: Creating an application security program should be a partnership, not a dictatorship. This approach recognizes that developers are key stakeholders in the security process, and their input and cooperation are essential for success.
Understanding the "Why": Developers are logical thinkers, and they are more likely to support a security program if they understand the reasons behind it. By explaining the "why" behind security measures and giving them the opportunity to voice concerns, security professionals can gain developer buy-in.
Reduced Resistance: When developers understand the importance of security and feel like their concerns are being heard, they are less likely to resist security measures. This can streamline the development process and reduce friction between security and development teams.
Policy Approval: Involving developers in the approval of security policies helps to ensure that the policies are practical, effective, and aligned with the realities of the development process. This also gives developers a sense of ownership and makes them more likely to adhere to the policies.
Proof of Concepts: Running proof of concepts for new security technologies with the development group that will be impacted allows developers to see the value of the technology firsthand, which can increase their willingness to adopt it.
Bilingual Approach: To be successful in application security, you need to be bilingual, speaking both developer and security languages. This means understanding the needs and concerns of developers and communicating security requirements in a way that resonates with them.
Additional reading: This article from Dark Reading advocates for "shift-left security," integrating security practices early in the software development life cycle (SDLC). The author, a security director, emphasizes collaboration between security and development teams, using tools like static application security testing (SAST) and software composition analysis (SCA).
Take a QA lead whose team uses risk-based testing to plan each sprint. Every story gets a risk score, the team tests the high scorers first, and the low scorers…